Disruptions and driver shortages - Printable Version +- North East Buses (https://northeastbuses.co.uk) +-- Forum: Local Bus Scene (https://northeastbuses.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: Management & Infrastructure (https://northeastbuses.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Thread: Disruptions and driver shortages (/showthread.php?tid=3532) |
RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Rob44 - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 8:11 am)Dan wrote Disappointed to see no match day 21 feedback from gtom this morning!Looked like they were running nspot on tbh. My 28b was spot on ans even got a bunch of drivers on who must have been having a beer at micro bus. Then there was the result!! ???? RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - MurdnunoC - 13 Nov 2022 It's quite disappointing actually. It's often entertaining to read about how badly GNE have done after a Newcastle match. You never see the same furore directed at the company after a Sunderland match. I wonder why that is? RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - BusLoverMum - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 11:49 am)MurdnunoC wrote It's quite disappointing actually. It's often entertaining to read about how badly GNE have done after a Newcastle match. You never see the same furore directed at the company after a Sunderland match. I wonder why that is?There is only so much of bustimes that it's possible to trawl in one sitting. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Unber43 - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 11:49 am)MurdnunoC wrote It's quite disappointing actually. It's often entertaining to read about how badly GNE have done after a Newcastle match. You never see the same furore directed at the company after a Sunderland match. I wonder why that is?For me its mainly because Im never in Sunderland when matches happen, however I do remember it being quite bad I think I was last stuck in traffic after a Sunderland match on the X36, we were about an hour late. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - F114TML - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 1:07 pm)Unber43 wrote For me its mainly because Im never in Sunderland when matches happen, however I do remember it being quite bad I think I was last stuck in traffic after a Sunderland match on the X36, we were about an hour late.The only time I've been on shift on a match day, I was on the 16 towards Grindon. I took over the bus (which had been told to run light to Wheatsheaf) 20 mins late, I did a run to Grindon and back to Red House. On return from Red House, I got to the stadium (I think just after the match had finished) on time with about 5 people on. I got to John Street 35 minutes late with about 55 people on (fight broke out on the bridge which gave us some entertainment). When I got to Hastings Hill I was told to terminate in the City Centre and run light to Red House for my last run of that part (then bus to depot) - a decker that IIRC was meant to be behind me did exactly the same and I followed it (I was 14-17 mins late throughout) until I terminated on John Street. And of course I still had people trying to get to Southwick/Red House even though I had 'City Centre' in giant letters on the front. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Unber43 - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 2:25 pm)F114TML wrote The only time I've been on shift on a match day, I was on the 16 towards Grindon.The amount of people which don't read the display. And just get on the bus cos of the colour. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - F114TML - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 3:59 pm)Unber43 wrote The amount of people which don't read the display.You could have "Mickey Mouse has a green willy" on the front and as long as the route number was right, people would get on. Worst one was when I was on the 16, I had "Fawcett Street" on the front, and a woman in Vine Place got on and asked where I was going to, I said 'only to the next stop'. "Oh. Are you still going to Red House, then?" RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - L469 YVK - 13 Nov 2022 (11 Nov 2022, 5:34 pm)streetdeckfan wrote Xlines wasn't failing until the flu came about though, passenger numbers actually increased for the first time in years (if MG is to be believed anyway)I think pre-covid, GNE had a fairly sensible strategy. XLines, "key" routes branded and corporate for anything else. Then during the recovery, things got a bit too "whacky" (Sunderland & District etc) rather than sticking to the basics. XLines should've been made genreric though. To give Arriva's Northumbria operation credit, things were quite stable during covid except the brief shortages at Jesmond depot and during the subsequent jobs market, managed to retain drivers until recently but now don't know how they'll fare after shutting Jesmond down. I do think if GNE's driver numbers recover, I could see them exploiting the gap north of Newcastle if Arriva's numbers don't recover. As for the rest of the ex Jesmond work bar the 306, maybe a situation like March 2022 & GNE in North Tyneside, where Arriva abandon the routes (51, 52, 53, 54, 55) and Nexus & NCC go out to tender with GCT & Stagecoach picking them up in some form or another. That'll then be Arriva's driver numbers sorted. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Storx - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 5:23 pm)L469 YVK wrote I think pre-covid, GNE had a fairly sensible strategy. What's your obsession with GNE 'exploiting North of Newcastle'. It would be nice for them to run their own services (11/12 (tunnel), 19, 51 (307), 317, 335, 342) without the tax payer having to foot the bill of them all. Also X-lines utterly sucked. It replaced brands which were easily recognisable with something that was a copy of Stagecoach Gold / Arriva Sapphire 10 years too late (ironic both those are now scrapped). Every X-Lines route has had a service reduction. Blaming Covid is a crap excuse and some of them are quite severe aswell. X20 - 100% X84/X85 - 100% X6/X7 - 50% X9/X10 - 50% X30/X31 - 50% X70/X71 - 50% X45/X46 - 50% (67% if you include the X47) X1 - 33% X21 - No Evenings 'Great' success that. Compare that to Arriva Northumbria MAX / Sapphire which sucks as it's Arriva: X21/X22 - No Change Sun - Fri, 33% Saturday X10/X11 - 33% 306/308 - No Change Sun - Fri, 33% Saturday X7/X8/X9 - No Change X20 - No Change X14 - Service Increase (acknowledge subsidy) X15 - No Change X16 - 100% X18 - No Change GNE can stay well away from around here for me with it's constant cutting exercises with it's fancy paint jobs to brainwash enthusiasts. If this was Arriva there would be outcry. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - L469 YVK - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 5:49 pm)Storx wrote What's your obsession with GNE 'exploiting North of Newcastle'. It would be nice for them to run their own services (11/12 (tunnel), 19, 51 (307), 317, 335, 342) without the tax payer having to foot the bill of them all.But what's going to happen if Arriva can't provide a suitable level of service on the 43/44/45? Jesmond's old moneymakers alongside the 306. Surely another operator who has the resources available would look to exploit the gap. As for GNE binning off a lot of routes, I agree with you on that especially the North Tyneside locals. But Arriva's 50 series routes, they're the types of routes that GNE would bin but Arriva have kept going. But are they going to be able to viably keep them going running out of Blyth / Ashington or will they pull the plug with Nexus / NCC picking up the pieces? RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Unber43 - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 4:09 pm)F114TML wrote You could have "Mickey Mouse has a green willy" on the front and as long as the route number was right, people would get on.With GNE its worse they just look at the colour and we all know how great GNE are at assigning their branded buses. Oh look theres the green bus(97), then ends up at Wardley. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - F114TML - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 6:37 pm)Unber43 wrote With GNE its worse they just look at the colour and we all know how great GNE are at assigning their branded buses.Best thing is when the Stagecoach training bus doesn't stop for passengers, GNE get the complaints RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Storx - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 6:07 pm)L469 YVK wrote But what's going to happen if Arriva can't provide a suitable level of service on the 43/44/45? Jesmond's old moneymakers alongside the 306. Think it all depends on how it works. The best scenario for everyone would be to sub contract some boards out similar to what GNE are to A-Line etc in the short term until they can get driver's. I know it's the sort of routes that GNE gave away but there's still scope for movement ie downgrading to minibuses. The fact that they haven't been would suggest they're not as bad as some people think (we'll never know of course). The costs of the depot though will surely outweight the costs of dead running. Jesmond was literally falling apart by the end you have to remember that, it's no different to CLS which was handled horrifically aswell and the driver issues there resolved pretty quickly bar Riverside which is still struggling to an extent. It'll be interesting to see what happens with GNE long term aswell as there's quite a few marginal routes at awkward depots, the 6 in particular. Both really messed up imo and just to add the third in because why not Stagecoach in Sunderland is an absolute shambles aswell. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - L469 YVK - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 7:44 pm)Storx wrote Think it all depends on how it works. The best scenario for everyone would be to sub contract some boards out similar to what GNE are to A-Line etc in the short term until they can get driver's.But will Arriva manage to recruit drivers? Given that they lost a fair chunk from Jesmond, gonna be very hard to replace not forgetting that Blyth & Ashington also have minor shortages too on top. Plus looking at things geographically, are there going to be many people in South East Northumberland looking to become bus drivers? And then anyone who lives further north in North Tyneside will likely be swayed by GNE (Percy Main) or Stagecoach (Walkergate / Slatyford) rather than Blyth or Ashington. Even if the 50 series routes all got downgraded to minibuses, are Arriva going to want the hassle of them routes including issues such as the Clean Air Zone that will cost money longer term? Asides from the the 306 that interworks with the 308 and the 43/44/45 which are money makers, the move to Blyth and Ashington is effectively Northumberland centered. The 51/52/53/54/55 barely touch Northumberland other than Cramlington (52/53). If Arriva can't find replacement drivers to fill the gaps plus the headaches of the 47 & 50's, I reckon the 47/51/52/53/54/55 would just go out to tender with Stagecoach picking up the full 685. That would automatically sort the driver numbers out for Blyth & Ashington including Blyth picking up the 306 (as now) and Ashington or Blyth picking up the 43/44/45. Going to be interesting in March as that is when the North Tyneside network tends to be reviewed with the Nexus contracts & tenders. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - PH - BQA - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 6:07 pm)L469 YVK wrote But what's going to happen if Arriva can't provide a suitable level of service on the 43/44/45? Jesmond's old moneymakers alongside the 306. What other operator will have the resources readily available? The M-F PVR of the 43/44/45 is 9. If we say around 2-3 drivers per bus per day, then you're looking at about 25 drivers per day needed to operate it. That's not accounting for Saturday or Sunday operation, holidays, driver sickness, driver training. So, as quite a conservative estimate, you'll need at least 30 drivers available to operate it if we assume there'll be some happy to do overtime. Given that all of the large operators are still, as far as I know, suffering to some degree from the shortage then I doubt any are in a position to actively seek that much work at present. (13 Nov 2022, 8:31 pm)L469 YVK wrote But will Arriva manage to recruit drivers? Given that they lost a fair chunk from Jesmond, gonna be very hard to replace not forgetting that Blyth & Ashington also have minor shortages too on top. The ANE driving school has had a constant influx of new drivers for a good period of time as far as I know. From what I've heard, any shortage at Ashington now is mainly due to sickness and holidays rather than being massively short of drivers on paper - I'm inclined to believe Blyth were similar pre-Jesmond work. Interestingly I know of a few ANE drivers who commute up to Northumberland out of Tyneside as they prefer driving routes there rather than crawl around Newcastle suburbs with Stagecoach. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Storx - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 8:31 pm)L469 YVK wrote But will Arriva manage to recruit drivers? Given that they lost a fair chunk from Jesmond, gonna be very hard to replace not forgetting that Blyth & Ashington also have minor shortages too on top. Not much to add what mb134 said so I'd just be parroting. One thing though is it'll be interesting to see what happens with Percy Main long term as they don't particularly have any work lately and I can't imagine there will be many people who want to run school buses which are the worst. They've only really got the 1, 19, 309/310/311 and 41/41A now and they could lose the 1 in the evenings and 19 in whole if the contracts go wrong. The wages between the two aren't miles apart now either being £12.65 at Arriva vs £12.83 at GNE according to latest job adverts so that could be a positive for people picking Arriva not to mention the chore of urban work with Stagecoach which won't be some people's cup of tea. There's some drivers who are happily paid less on the minibus rota at Ashington to stay away from Newcastle. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - L469 YVK - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 9:04 pm)Storx wrote Not much to add what mb134 said so I'd just be parroting.I think we all know the situation with GNE to be fair but they must see some value keeping it for some reason or another? But the question given Blyth / Ashington plus driver shortages, is are the 47 and 50's worth keeping or binning off come March and letting Nexus tender out to GCT/Stagecoach/GNE? Regarding MB134's post, if Arriva bin the 47 and 50's off (and give the 685 fully to Stagecoach), that'll leave a suitable number of drivers to adequately cover Blyth & Ashingtons work including 306/308 boards and the 43/44/45. Therefore the reliability issues on the 43/44/45 would be sorted with a suitable number of drivers available to cover. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Unber43 - 13 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 8:35 pm)mb134 wrote What other operator will have the resources readily available?Also, where are GNE going to get the Euro 6 spares from, while Im not against an expansion of GNE north of Newcastle, where are they going to store all the buses, Percy Main is full of school routes, Riverside is probably quite full not to mention the awful drivers shortages which the depot is experiencing, while GNE do plan to recruit 100 new drivers, when/if that is done how many would have left in that time, and they probs need 30-40 for just the routes they need day-in-day-out. The only way I could see any expansion is if another company goes bust and they have euro 6 single & double deckers available for purchase and where able to comfortably operate it. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Ambassador - 14 Nov 2022 21s ran fine, aside 20 minute gaps, going to Newcastle for match day for a nice change, much better performance than Wednesday.. The late kick off obviously helps and shows there’s large numbers of people travelling to Newcastle or on the roads for reasons beyond football on your average Saturday. I used the X12 from the cannon into the match as there’d been no 21 for 20 minutes which isn’t too unusual and the X21 wasn’t tracking but did appear to run behind my X12 Had a long wait for a 21 home and My chariot home last night was full and standing from High Level, including the upper deck which drivers don’t seem to bother about now but made it incredibly difficult to get off, The drinkers and post match crowd mix was again fairly manageable. Eldon Square remains a dismally disorganised place to wait for a bus mind and Newcastle council really need to solve the John Dobson street into Central Motorway junction. It’s a real bottle neck and all buses get trapped RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - tcts24 - 14 Nov 2022 (13 Nov 2022, 4:09 pm)F114TML wrote You could have "Mickey Mouse has a green willy" on the front and as long as the route number was right, people would get on.Think my favorite to date is a feew weeks ago on route 1 terminating at Seaton Carew. Obviously when I got to Elzabeth way, I'd left the destination as "Seaton Carew". It's company policy to stop anyway even though you know they won't get on. So stopped for a man and small girl on the sea front and immediately told him "It's only going as far as the Schooner", to which he replied "but it says town centre on the front". I then told him it doesn't, it says Seaton Carew and repeated that I finish at the Schooner. Off I went and a few stops later stopped for a woman and of course told her I finish at the Schooner. Her reply was "but it says Seaton Carew on the front". Now this confused me, so I looked blankly at her for a few seconds and finally replied "it does and we're in Seaton and this is where it finishes and I'm going back to the depot". I've no idea where she thought she was. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - F114TML - 14 Nov 2022 (14 Nov 2022, 10:04 am)tcts24 wrote Think my favorite to date is a feew weeks ago on route 1 terminating at Seaton Carew. Obviously when I got to Elzabeth way, I'd left the destination as "Seaton Carew". It's company policy to stop anyway even though you know they won't get on. So stopped for a man and small girl on the sea front and immediately told him "It's only going as far as the Schooner", to which he replied "but it says town centre on the front". I then told him it doesn't, it says Seaton Carew and repeated that I finish at the Schooner. Off I went and a few stops later stopped for a woman and of course told her I finish at the Schooner. Her reply was "but it says Seaton Carew on the front". Now this confused me, so I looked blankly at her for a few seconds and finally replied "it does and we're in Seaton and this is where it finishes and I'm going back to the depot". I've no idea where she thought she was.Ex-GNE driver told me this story. He was going onto the 60. He came into Park Lane with NIS on the front, loaded up the coffin dodgers going to Seaham (without changing the board) and as a joke made the announcements say "This is the 9 service to Jarrow". Ohh how I wish I'd have been there to see their faces RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - tcts24 - 14 Nov 2022 Sounds similar to when I'd went to Owton Manor as a 6 and for whatever reason forgot to change the destination to "7 The Headland". Nobody questioned it all the way to Hartlepool centre where I filled up with shoppers and the likes going home. Somebody FINALLY told me I still had "6 Owton Marnor & Fens" on the front, at which point I changesd it and announced I was actually a 7. Must have been nearly 30 people stood up and piled back off the bus. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - deanmachine - 14 Nov 2022 (14 Nov 2022, 10:42 am)F114TML wrote Ex-GNE driver told me this story. He was going onto the 60. A few weeks ago I had a Drifter on the 9, destination correct, correct stand, NSAs working, and I got as far as Fulwell Grange before a woman came to the front and said "is this not the 60?! I wanted to go to Seaham". RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - nova347 - 14 Nov 2022 (14 Nov 2022, 5:34 pm)deanmachine wrote A few weeks ago I had a Drifter on the 9, destination correct, correct stand, NSAs working, and I got as far as Fulwell Grange before a woman came to the front and said "is this not the 60?! I wanted to go to Seaham".I was once on Drifter on the 20 and we got to Sunderland College and someone started having a go at the driver and saying Do you not know the route? You went the totally wrong way? What's the driver number I'm reporting you? The number of people who look at the branding and not the destination display is beyond a joke, I remember when I was in Secondary one of my friends was waiting for the 60 and because it was a Corporate Streetlite and not a Drifter she let it drive past because and I quote "I was waiting for a blue bus". RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Unber43 - 14 Nov 2022 Anyone know why X10 is going through Hartlepool? RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Storx - 14 Nov 2022 (14 Nov 2022, 9:06 pm)Unber43 wrote Anyone know why X10 is going through Hartlepool? A19 overnight closure. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - tcts24 - 15 Nov 2022 (14 Nov 2022, 9:06 pm)Unber43 wrote Anyone know why X10 is going through Hartlepool?Must be over a month its been doing that on a night. Certainly saw it take some interesting diversions when I'm going the other way with my 7 RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Andreos1 - 15 Nov 2022 (14 Nov 2022, 9:06 pm)Unber43 wrote Anyone know why X10 is going through Hartlepool? Works on the A19 again. Putting right the absolute cowboy job that was done when they widenened and resurfaced some of the section between Wolviston and Norton. I think this is the 3rd time they've been back, since the initial works were finished last year. They're doing a portion of resurfacing beyond the Wolviston on slip on the northbound section at the mo off memory. Which means diverting via Hartlepool or Sedgefield/The Trimdons. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Storx - 15 Nov 2022 (15 Nov 2022, 12:48 pm)Andreos1 wrote Works on the A19 again. It's nothing to do with the widening mind. It's just the last remaining part of concrete that was outside the scheme. Not an easy thing to get arid of hence the nighttime closures for weeks in probably the worst place to have a closure on the A19 in terms of diversions. RE: Disruptions and driver shortages - Unber43 - 15 Nov 2022 (15 Nov 2022, 12:48 pm)Andreos1 wrote Works on the A19 again.Talking about widening roads, widening roads does not decrease journey time, it actually increases it. |