You need to enable JavaScript to run this app.

Skip to main content

The NOT City Transport Thread

RE: The NOT City Transport Thread
(21 Aug 2026, 7:39 pm)MurdnunoC Wrote: Of course, it won't be his fault. Never is. The judge, the jury, the traffic commissioner will all be misinformed and wrong in some way.

I wonder if the TCO have had an email demanding that the information isn't placed on their website?

You know, brush the shitty behaviour under the carpet, don't ever consider changing your ways.
Forum Moderator | Find NEB on facebook
RE: The NOT City Transport Thread
Quite enjoyed this bit:

Quote:VEM Williams proceeded to investigate the complaints and provided detailed explanations into each Prohibition Notice.

The following is a summary of VEM Williams’ findings:
  • The ‘detached hub’ vehicle YJ04FYT prohibition should have been ‘S’ marked (denoting a significant failure in roadworthiness compliance),
  • VE Williams particularly noted the failure to comply with the PSV 112 notification of a serious road safety incident,
  • Prohibitions were correctly issued to vehicle W671CWX
  • Regarding the operator’s claim that vehicle SN55BPO should not have attracted a prohibition for insufficient tyre tread depth as it was under repair, VE Williams asked the rhetorical question, “How can a vehicle have a tyre below legal limit if not being used?”
  • The Operator’s claims of vehicle SN55BPO not being in service for a number of weeks before 24th April 2023, was refuted by Automatic Number Plate Recognition (“ANPR”) data, showing use on 8 separate dates in April. As such, VEM Williams reviewed the prohibition and asked the examiner to delete the original prohibition and replace it with an ‘S’ marked Prohibition Notice.

This bit too:

Quote:
  • MOT fail rate at 43%, initial fail, being significantly higher than the national 10% figure.
  • Based on this investigation, the VE refers to continuous and effective management by the TM not existing and the TM as being “obstructive”.
  • A response to the findings of the MIVR was issued by the Operator in January 2024. This report was not signed nor was it dated, so the author could not be confirmed by VE Mann. The response addressed each section of the MIVR, refuting several of the findings and providing explanations as to why the alleged shortcomings had occurred. The Operator also provided assurances as to how the issues would be rectified going forward.
  • Upon receipt of the Operator’s response, VE Mann marked the response as ‘unsatisfactory’, stating “this is an experienced Operator but yet the maintenance arrangements still seem to be in disarray. For the safety of all road users concerned – in my opinion a major commitment in improvement is required in maintenance standards to uphold this operator’s undertakings”. (pg. 247)
  • The VE also states, “when prohibition notices are issued there seems to be a desperate search for a maintenance provider to repair the defects. Vehicles are scrapped rather than re-tested. This leaves me concerned regarding the standards of the vehicles if they are not cost effective to repair. For example, vehicle YJ07VXU – one prohibition notice in a sequence of events, resulted in the vehicle being written off. It begs the question, who the regular maintenance team was at the time?” (pg.247)
  • The statement of garage director, Ryan Jackson, “they wanted a bodge, I will never put my name or business to such a low standard of work” highlights VE Mann’s concerns. (pg. 264)
RE: The NOT City Transport Thread
(Yesterday, 3:51 pm)citaro5284 Wrote: Looks like someone asked for a FOI regarding formal warnings and termination of the Sunderland Connect Contract - 3 formal warnings regarding lost mileage, vehicle spec and Euro ratings....at least it was a bit of everything that got the contract terminated

https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/s...5hwyg6ZT0A

Now that is interesting. Not quite the story we were all told about fuel poverty.

  1. On the 23rd March 2026, City received a letter of a second formal warning, with a note that the contract would be terminated should there be reason to issue a further formal warning.
  2. 31st March/1st April 2026, Nexus spot checked them again twice to ascertain whether the USB ports had been fitted and working (they hadn't). They also spotted that one vehicle didn't have CCTV fitted, which is a separate breach of contract.
  3. In the meantime, on the 5th April 2026, City issue a letter claiming fuel poverty and offering a voluntary termination (see: Facebook post)
  4. On 15th April 2026, 10 days later, they finally receive their third formal warning and termination.

City issued their letter a couple of days after they were spot checked twice. Whilst fuel prices are a very real issue, starting around that time, its hard to imagine that they weren't expecting the termination letter at this point. 

Plus, they're still running articulated buses in service. Buses GNE stated were only achieving 4-5mpg in service. Regardless of what you're earning on a contract, it's absolutely bonkers business to still run these in service at the current diesel prices.
Forum Moderator | Find NEB on facebook
RE: The NOT City Transport Thread
(Yesterday, 5:42 pm)Adrian Wrote: Now that is interesting. Not quite the story we were all told about fuel poverty.

  1. On the 23rd March 2026, City received a letter of a second formal warning, with a note that the contract would be terminated should there be reason to issue a further formal warning.
  2. 31st March/1st April 2026, Nexus spot checked them again twice to ascertain whether the USB ports had been fitted and working (they hadn't). They also spotted that one vehicle didn't have CCTV fitted, which is a separate breach of contract.
  3. In the meantime, on the 5th April 2026, City issue a letter claiming fuel poverty and offering a voluntary termination (see: Facebook post)
  4. On 15th April 2026, 10 days later, they finally receive their third formal warning and termination.

City issued their letter a couple of days after they were spot checked twice. Whilst fuel prices are a very real issue, starting around that time, its hard to imagine that they weren't expecting the termination letter at this point. 

Plus, they're still running articulated buses in service. Buses GNE stated were only achieving 4-5mpg in service. Regardless of what you're earning on a contract, it's absolutely bonkers business to still run these in service at the current diesel prices.

Can't wait until the next YouTube video explaining how this is all wrong and how they were persecuted by the evil Nexus, thus forcing them to relinquish the contract for the greater good or something....
RE: The NOT City Transport Thread
(Yesterday, 5:42 pm)Adrian Wrote: Now that is interesting. Not quite the story we were all told about fuel poverty.

  1. On the 23rd March 2026, City received a letter of a second formal warning, with a note that the contract would be terminated should there be reason to issue a further formal warning.
  2. 31st March/1st April 2026, Nexus spot checked them again twice to ascertain whether the USB ports had been fitted and working (they hadn't). They also spotted that one vehicle didn't have CCTV fitted, which is a separate breach of contract.
  3. In the meantime, on the 5th April 2026, City issue a letter claiming fuel poverty and offering a voluntary termination (see: Facebook post)
  4. On 15th April 2026, 10 days later, they finally receive their third formal warning and termination.

City issued their letter a couple of days after they were spot checked twice. Whilst fuel prices are a very real issue, starting around that time, its hard to imagine that they weren't expecting the termination letter at this point. 

Plus, they're still running articulated buses in service. Buses GNE stated were only achieving 4-5mpg in service. Regardless of what you're earning on a contract, it's absolutely bonkers business to still run these in service at the current diesel prices.

I haven't got much to add on what you've said there but there appears to be at least a 4th formal notice on the 23rd February that the USB Chargers MUST be fitted by the 31st March so there's clearly more to it. What that says, who knows but I only guess it's on the lines of USB Chargers Fitted by 31st March or contract terminated.

Whether there's even more, who knows, but it's only warnings that have been asked for. The fact that the second notice was served on the 23rd and they were out like a hawk on the deadline doesn't paint a good relationship though but that's speculation.
RE: The NOT City Transport Thread
I wonder how this affects the TUPE situation?

Given it was likely City Transport would have been stripped of the contract anyway, and that the contract was voluntarily handed back in light of this, would a tribunal consider that the loss of the contract was due to the incompetence of the operator rather than financial circumstances beyond their control?

Does being stripped of a contractual obligation differ from choosing to walk to walk away when it comes to something like TUPE?
RE: The NOT City Transport Thread
What is the point of installing USB ports - there useless and too slow.
RE: The NOT City Transport Thread
(4 hours ago)MurdnunoC Wrote: I wonder how this affects the TUPE situation?
[snip]
Does being stripped of a contractual obligation differ from choosing to walk to walk away when it comes to something like TUPE?

No, it doesn't make a difference to whether the staff are protected by TUPE.
It is easy to find more on-line. For example, in reply to the question "does TUPE still apply if the contract is lost due to failure to perform?", SearchAssist's reply is:
  • TUPE can still apply when a service contract is lost because the contractor failed to perform. The key issue is whether the work transfers to a replacement provider and remains fundamentally the same for the same client; the reason the contract ended does not by itself decide whether TUPE applies.