(09 Jul 2017, 3:55 pm)Tamesider wrote I suppose the subtle difference between GM and the North East is that until 2014 there was virtually no competition between the "big 5". The exception being Bolton/Wigan, but apart from the 575 between Horwich and Bolton, this is largely due to the pre-dereg services inherited anyway. When First bought Finglands in 2013/4, the idea of First and Stagecoach going head to head was totally new. As such, its turned into a local version of World War 3, with "collateral" way beyond (nay, solely beyond) the battlefield.
There has always been competition between subsidised rail and commercial bus on a limited number of markets, but Rail will always be the winner there, but the change in overall circumstances triggered by the First/Stagecoach bus war, has created problems and oppurtunities for the rail industry. It is significant that the recent round of off-peak fare increases excluded journeys that competed with buses, so as to maintain a clear financial advantage for customers able to drive to the Station (or park on a neighbouring residential street). For instance a full fare payer from where I live to the far side of Manchester city centre will pay £3.60 on the train/Metrolink, but £5.80 on the bus/Metrolink. These are Return fares. The gap is narrower at peak times of course, but that hasn't stopped a massive increase in use of my evening peak train, for instance, such that it is ringing alarm bells in TFGM's Rail department. But as their influence is solely strategic, there is nothing they can do about carriage allocation, individual fares and stopping policy of existing lines in the short term
I think any bus competition up here is a legacy of how the network was split up in 86 too.
Arriva (formerly United in this example) worked alongside GNE for a period in joint operated services between Newcastle and Durham and beyond. Now they compete on sections of the route having divided operations up on other parts.
The 722/723 was joint worked. Arriva have the southern section as the 7. GNE has the northern section as the 21. The Arriva X12 being a half hourly interloper into the Northern part.
Arriva (Northumbria) ended up in competiton with GNE east out of Newcastle along the Coast Road following de-reg. To a lesser extent Stagecoach (T&W PTE). There is also the Metro to take in to account.
TWPTE/Nexus funded the BR local services within Tyne & Wear. This continued following privatisation and they now operate the metro between Newcastle and Sunderland. Bus competition between the two points that shadowed the line has always failed. Both prior to and since the Metro was extended.
Within Sunderland and it's outlying environs, Go Ahead had the distance stuff and ran in competition with United to the south. This has continued to an extent. Within the City, Stagecoach (previously the PTE and Busways) got rid of the majority of any independents and often compete with GNE.
Further afield in Co Durham, independent operators have long gone or have been bought out.
The rest of the network is carved up pretty nicely, with Arriva and GNE having routes left to them that their predessessors operated both prior to and after de-reg.
'Illegitimis non carborundum'