(12 Jan 2020, 6:22 pm)OrangeArrow49 wrote
Branding or not is certainly an interesting debate and I have long been conflicted about whether I like identity branding like GNE, uniform branding like Stagecoach or uniform livery with sub-branding like Arriva. There are of course exceptions too, GNE has a corporate livery, Stagecoach introduced a green livery for their hybrids and has long had a Metrocentre brand for the 100 shuttle and more recently the 6/7. Arriva also has different liveries such as Coastliner, the NHS and Quorum Solos, the purple/grey livery and older and newer corporate liveries. Independents largely have a uniform livery, Stanley Travel white and blue with or without red, GCT using the Nexus Bus livery of grey and red, A-Line either white or grey and pink. Uniform/corporate branding is certainly more instantly recognisable and consistent. Identities like with GNE are iconic, for example Quaylink has long been the iconic yellow for running around the Quayside, and can be useful 'Tynedale/Tyne Valley', 'Quaylink', 'Cobalt and Coast/Coaster/Little Coasters', relevant to a service or area served 'Red Kite, Angel, Black Cats ' but can also be daft 'The 9/The 49, Connection4, Fab 56, City Link 57/58, Toon Link, Green/Blue Arrow' etc.
Consistent branding is a good compromise, like we are seeing now with the new and refreshed identities like Cobalt & Coast, Little Coasters, Green Arrow, and X-lines.
Thoughts?
I like the approach that GNE are taking.
I personally find Stagecoach boring, I don't even see their buses driving through Newcastle anymore, they just blend in. (maybe that's why they keep having 'incidents'!)
I like the idea behind Arriva's, but as with everything they do, the execution just hasn't worked. What is the difference between MAX and Sapphire? Wasn't Sapphire supposed to be posh with dedicated drivers and uniform? Are MAX routes express? What even is Arriva's current livery?!
While we are losing some good brands, I think simplifying the branding is a good idea. I'm really coming round to X-Lines! I'm not a fan of Cobalt and Coast, it just seems a bit half-arsed to me. But I do like Little Coasters and Green Arrows, they're bright but not over the top (like Fab 56!)
What I would like to see is something like X-Lines but for the more urban routes.
So basically, what I'm saying is GNE should just take what Arriva did with MAX and Sapphire, but put effort into making them good!